Tuesday, November 18, 2014

Classic Simpsons review: "Simpsons Roasting On an Open Fire" - John Papovitch

By the time the first episode of The Simpsons aired in 1989, a regular Fox viewer would already know them from their vignettes on The Tracey Ullman Show – the sketch comedy show that spawned a series that would be running 25 years later running over 500 episodes and a theatrical feature film. Even as this first episode, “The Simpsons Christmas Special” unravels, one can see that the groundwork for this popular series is already in place. While the show would start to become better over time, the series’ humble beginnings are off to a satisfying start.

The episode begins at Springfield Elementary, where Bart and Lisa are performing in the school’s holiday pageant. Lisa does a traditional tribal fire dance, while Bart opts to sing “Jingle bells, Batman smells…” before promptly being pulled off the stage. As the episode progresses, Marge has to spend all her Christmas gift money on removing an unfinished tattoo Bart decided to get for himself. On the same hand, Homer learns that Mr. Burns is not giving out Christmas bonuses this year and thus, to avoid disappointing his family, takes a job as a mall Santa.

The job does not go according to plan and all Homer gets out of it is a measly $13.  Barney encourages Homer to go to the dog track in hopes their luck will change. Homer bets 99 to one on a dog named Santa’s Little Helper, insisting it’s a holiday miracle. Alas the dog does not even place. In the parking lot, Santa’s Little Helper is abandoned by his owner and Homer takes the dog home – bringing home a perfect Christmas gift – something to share the family’s love.

The fact that this is an episode from the show’s first season really shows. While it was not the first episode produced, the series still has not found its true voice just yet. Compared to the pacing of later episodes – this one is more subdued, slower, and quieter.  The animation is not refined and to be honest is not very good. The combination of so-so animation and quieter humor style makes this very much a product of its time, especially given what The Simpsons turned into a few years later with the more bizarre, satirical edge the show received, the more realistic setting Springfield was early on is reflected in this episode.


But, despite all that, while this is not the smartest, best-written episode, it’s still a good episode of what The Simpsons was at the time which, even then, is nothing particularly bad – it just hasn’t found itself yet. As a standalone Christmas special, it’s one to very much admire. While the show has done numerous other Christmas episodes over the years – to me, this one stands out as the best one because of how earnest and less silly the style of comedy is. It may be a product of its time in the show’s history, but the product as a whole still works. Just don’t expect it to be one of the series’ great episodes. 

Critic emulated: Robert Canning (IGN)

No comments:

Post a Comment